Confessions of a Theoholic

Thursday, October 25, 2012

Who Has Been Left Behind?

In my limited circles today, I see 2 main emphases--church planting and campus ministries. Both of these I see as profitable and good ministry foci. However, have we perhaps gone overboard? Is there some ministry or demographic in which we are not reaching? My answer is Yes! In our zeal to plant new churches and reach the college crowd (which is not wrong), we are leaving behind those established churches where the congregation is now comprised of a small and older generation of believers (which is wrong). In our zeal to reach the young and suburbia, we have left behind the old and the urban. Why is this a problem you may ask? If heaven is composed of people from every tribe, tongue, family, and nation, then shouldn't our local church reflect a little bit of heaven; not just in our worship, but in our demographic composition? If Paul assumes the existence of an older generation within the church (1 Tim 5; Titus 2), what does that say about our ignoring them? What are we saying when we focus on one demographic to the exclusion of another or other demographics? Do we believe that older people (or minority people) still are God's image-bearers? Do we believe that older believers (or minority believers) have giftings from God that can be used for the benefit of the church? Do not all people need the Gospel--young, old, black, white, rich, poor?

In terms of one called to ministry, the reality is that straight out of seminary, one is most likely not going to be called to a church that is similar to the one in which they interned and worshiped during their time in seminary. If the reality is that most churches are small to middle-sized and can only afford 1 pastor, then why not do an internship in such a church to understand the expectations and problems that arise from such a situation? It certainly will be different than the issues and problems that arise in a larger church or church that can afford multiple pastors.

In terms of a young family, we love for our kids to see their grandparents. Why would we not want them to have spiritual grandparents? Why do we want our kids to only interact with people like their mom and dad? Not only is this good social development for them, but more importantly it is also a demonstration of a robust ecclesiology. It is doctrine lived out. They get to get a glimpse of how the church reflects heaven to a degree. They get exposure to people from various walks of life and backgrounds.

A robust doctrine of the church (ecclesiology) must include a robust demographic. It must include people from every tribe, tongue, nation, and family. If not, we should make every effort that it does. This means that alongside church planting and college ministry, we need to have equal emphasis upon church revitalization and renewal.

2 Comments:

  • Thanks for the post, Mark. A lot of good thoughts and important things to consider, especially for the ARP!

    You are right that most denominations and networks are imbalanced. Sometimes this is unfaithfulness. Other times it is the contextual and regional situation of the denomination. For example, the ARP probably shouldn't start a Pacific Northwest church planting network...at least not before we have trained, capable men who can run such a network, or until we have had more success in church planting.

    In terms of how we ingraft older, declining churches full of older people, I think there are a number of options available so that these folks might feel 'included' as a denomination or presbytery pursues missional endeavors such as campus ministry or church planting.

    First, church plants that are near these older, dying churches might be a means to help revitalize/re-mission these churches. Church planting experts believe that church plants are able to help revitalize older churches and help them be on mission. This is sort of what is happening in Catawba Presbytery.

    Second, an older, dying church might undergo the process of revitalizing/re-missioning by calling a 'church-plant' type pastor who will feed the flock on the Lord's Day, but spend the rest of the week focusing on gathering a core group, starting an evening service, doing outreach, etc. so that the church as a whole is revitalized with new believers, new families, etc. The older congregation's role, with being fed at the same time, is prayer, tithing, support, and hospitality. I know of at least one ARP church doing this model.

    A third way is to poor in lots of funding into an older church like one would with a church plant. We are doing this with one church in First Presbytery, and the goal is to not just grow the church but to also recruit seminary interns.

    I think you are right, Mark, that seminary students would be better suited to intern at these smaller, older churches (or a church plant) since they will likely be called to this kind of church rather than a multi-staff church or a campus ministry.

    We need creativity going forward. I think our denomination has the potential to do a lot in this area. Probably the main hindrance is that there is a lot of disunity when it comes to philosophy of ministry and theological vision for revitalization and church planting. I'm not sure how such unity will be fostered apart from the Holy Spirit being at work. Maybe getting pastors and leaders in the same presbytery in the same room to pray, read Scripture, and discuss these ministry issues would be a step in the right direction.

    Thanks again for the post, Mark. Good stuff.

    By Blogger Daniel F. Wells, At October 25, 2012 at 2:02 PM  

  • Good stuff Daniel. I always appreciate your insight and feedback. As I have spent the last few months thinking about this, I have come to see how closely-related and overlapping church-planting and revitalization can be. Those are some good models (some of which I was not aware of) which give me good food for thought. Good way to bring those 2 together instead of treating them as separate approaches. Perhaps that's what you and I can do. You bring the church planting emphasis and I can bring the revitalization/renewal emphasis. :)

    By Blogger Pastor Mark, At October 25, 2012 at 2:07 PM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]



<< Home